Week 18 Fantasy Football Rankings: The Weird, the Wild, and The Chalk
Week 18 is the wild west of fantasy football -- but man it's fun. John Laghezza shares his rankings thoughts!
Most of the players I’m willing to bet on producing will need a properly motivated environment to get there. Assume any player or team not mentioned crosses too far into the realm of replacement.
Here are the Fantasy Life official Week 18 rankings, from the inimitable (and accuracy-challenge winning Rob "Waz" Waziak).
Now let's dig into mine!
We'll start at the top since only three games out of 16 this weekend actually matter, and those stakes couldn’t be higher. Seattle at San Francisco, Carolina at Tampa Bay, and Baltimore at Pittsburgh all carry direct postseason implications—with the latter two representing true playoff-style win-or-go-home consequences. Needless to say, almost regardless of game totals, the most reliable utilization will be found here.
The Games That Mean Something
The 49ers defense ranks with the very worst, creating the weekly carnivals us fantasy gamers love so much—which is why Jaxon Smith-Njigba is this weekend’s top-ranked player. Push up all Seahawks, especially TE A.J. Barner, who I’m penciling in for a big game Saturday night. Ditto for Cooper Kupp — and all of San Fran’s bit players. Seattle’s a scary matchup but Kyle Shanahan and Brock Purdy are commanding the league’s most prolific offense right now. Strike where the iron’s hot.
If one of these games flops in terms of scoring it’s probably the CAR/TB NFC South showdown, which could very well send a .500 team to the dance as divisional champs. Sadly for my bankroll, every time I want/need/expect Baker Mayfield and the boys to go bananas, they disappoint. Maybe he’s injured or the timing’s not right, I’m struggling to buy into what either team’s selling this weekend. Yes, both Jalen McMillan and Mike Evans went for seven grabs and over 100 yards Sunday but predicting where the production will come is harder than when.
When Baltimore kicks off in the Steel City, it’s about whether or not Lamar Jackson suits up. Personally, I think after practicing Wednesday, the two-time MVP is about to go nuclear over the next month, silencing his critics once and for all. Boost Derrick Henry and Zay Flowers into the slate’s top tier for a potential rout. Don’t forget to circle Kenneth Gainwell — without DK Metcalf, he could catch 10 balls in a negative game script.
"A Virtual Hodgepodge"
After that, it’s a virtual hodgepodge of incentive chasing and resting the wounded. One by one, teams go from unattractive to totally toxic. For a second it looked like Green Bay might roll out Malik Willis again, which would make him a must-start along with deep threat WR Christian Watson. However, Willis (shoulder) hasn’t thrown a football in practice yet and I’m starting to worry he’ll sit. Remember, GB is locked into the #7 seed. There goes that idea…
Next is the group of NFC teams that could move around the standings — and they also provide a valuable lesson. Rest matters to coaches, a lot—which is exactly why forecasting Week 18 is so difficult. Philly could snatch the second seed and potential home field at some point with a win plus Chicago loss, but Nick Sirianni’s not interested. Philadelphia already announced they’ll be resting starters. But what if, as they’re about to sit Jalen Hurts and A.J. Brown, the Lions go up by two scores? I mention this because there’s some love for Tanner McKee floating around after Sirianni's announcement that could easily go bust.
CHI and LAR could be playing throughout depending on the situation. Queue up your Luther Burden and Colston Loveland shares without fear to secure the two-seed, though I wouldn’t write anything in marker just yet when it comes to the Rams—they’ll be locked into the #6 seed if the 49ers win on Saturday. If Seattle pulls it off, start Puka Nacua and all the usual suspects, including emerging weapon Colby Parkinson.
On to...
The Wild World of the AFC
Jacksonville just might be my favorite play in the conference. Not only do they face a horrific Titans squad, but they'll be in position to acquire the top seed since DEN and NE both play in the afternoon. Force Trevor Lawrence, Travis Etienne, and Jakobi Meyers into every lineup. They’re playing the same time as Houston, who could grab the third seed with a win plus Jags’ loss versus a decimated Indianapolis defense—get C.J. Stroud, Woody Marks, Nico Collins, and Jayden Higgins atop your weekly ranks.
As far as the aforementioned Broncos and Bills go, prioritize Denver for the clearer path against the Chargers, who already announced they’re sitting Justin Herbert and accompanying starters. A win for Bo Nix means the AFC’s top seed and home field advantage throughout, putting RJ Harvey, Courtland Sutton, and perhaps even Troy Franklin into smash spots Sunday against backups.
Tempting as it might be to challenge fate in one of the remaining dumpster fires, I’m out. Whether it’s Dallas at New York, Cleveland at Cincinnati, or Kansas City at Las Vegas, there’s entirely too many question marks to plant any flags. Even if you’re looking good in the first half, there’s zero certainty it sustains with nothing on the line.
Thanks for reading and good luck! Happy New Year!
