New York Giants NFL Draft Grade - Report Card and Fantasy Value of Jaxson Dart and Cam Skattebo

Thor Nystrom breaks down his NFL Draft grade for the 2025 draft alongside Ian Hartitz's fantasy football fallout of their draft.

Who Did the New York Giants Draft?

Abdul Carter, EDGE
Jaxson Dart, QB
Darius Alexander, DL
Cam Skattebo, RB
Marcus Mbow, OG
Thomas Fidone II, TE
Korie Black, CB

Grading the Giants NFL Draft

*1-2 sentences introducing Thor’s grading system/point scores and adding table.

New York Giants Fantasy Football Outlook for 2025

Jaxson Dart, QB

It's unfortunate the Giants are planning to stick with Russell Wilson as their starter to open the season, as Dart's demonstrated rushing goodness (averaged 499 rush yards and 4 TD per season from 2022-24, including sacks) could have separated him from the low-end QB2 pocket passers.

Alas, the NFL's youngest (potential) starting QB looks more like a stash for 2026 and beyond as opposed to someone 2025 re-draft fantasy managers should be getting overly excited about.

Cam Skattebo, RB

Day 3 draft capital is seldom good for rookie RBs, but then again, Skattebo lands on a Giants depth chart with very little competition in Tyrone Tracy and Devin Singletary.

Could Skattebo simply have more dog in him and emerge as the offense's workhorse? Yes! Could Brian Daboll also more or less decide to form a fairly evenly split three-back committee? Also yes.

Ultimately, Skattebo's big-time receiving numbers at Arizona State make him the sort of rare late-round prospect worth betting on; just don't get too carried away when comparing him against guys like Omarion Hampton and Kaleb Johnson.

More 2025 NFL Draft Grades By Team

Arizona Cardinals Draft Grade
Atlanta Falcons Draft Grade
Baltimore Ravens Draft Grade
Buffalo Bills Draft Grade
Carolina Panthers Draft Grade
Chicago Bears Draft Grade
Cincinnati Bengals Draft Grade
Cleveland Browns Draft Grade
Dallas Cowboys Draft Grade
Denver Broncos Draft Grade
Detroit Lions Draft Grade
Green Bay Packers Draft Grade
Houston Texans Draft Grade
Indianapolis Colts Draft Grade
Jacksonville Jaguars Draft Grade
Kansas City Chiefs Draft Grade
Las Vegas Raiders Draft Grade
Los Angeles Chargers Draft Grade
Los Angeles Rams Draft Grade
Miami Dolphins Draft Grade
Minnesota Vikings Draft Grade
New England Patriots Draft Grade
New Orleans Saints Draft Grade
New York Giants Draft Grade
New York Jets Draft Grade
Philadelphia Eagles Draft Grade
Pittsburgh Steelers Draft Grade
San Francisco 49ers Draft Grade
Seattle Seahawks Draft Grade
Tampa Bay Buccaneers Draft Grade
Tennessee Titans Draft Grade
Washington Commanders Draft Grade